January 25, 2021
Penguin Pool Murder (1932) ***
TCM
Free
Wildcard
I saw this movie in November 2019, which was the first time I got obsessed with TCM, and reviewed it then on Letterboxd. I do not feel the need to re-review it, since I think I did it pretty well the first time. So I’m cutting and pasting it here, thanks, past me!
I said at the time I would try and see the rest of the Miss Withers series, which I did not, but now in the present, the next one is on the app, but also the whole series is available on DVD from Warner Archives, so I will fulfill that promise to myself after all.
********************
Here is what I love about TCM and why I have taken to filling up the DVR with its output: TCM loves showing extremely random movies, not just classics that you’ve heard of, or movies that you always meant to see, but movies you had no idea ever existed. Have you ever heard of Penguin Pool Murder? Did you know that the glorious Edna May Oliver did a series of movies about teacher and amateur sleuth, Miss Hildegarde Withers? Of course not, who ever heard of such a thing! But I know now, and so do you.
Gerald Parker is a stockbroker, and given that this movie is from 1932, that means that he is an extreme villain who ruins people without a care, aka a deserving murder victim to be. His wife meets up with her ex at the aquarium, he follows, the ex pushes him so lightly that it wouldn’t even wake a sleeping infant, but he is knocked out instantly. The ex drags him behind the scenes where penguins react indignantly, later, he drops into the penguin tank, stone dead.
Miss Withers has a fantastic entrance, in that a miscreant snatches a purse and tries to run away, evading capture, until Our Heroine, whilst shepherding her class through the aquarium, trips him handily with her umbrella. We instantly understand that the killer, whether it turns out to be the ex or not (seems a little easy if it is), will have no chance against her.
Miss Withers teams up with the inspector on the case, and goes off to interrogate the dead man’s secretary. She finds the secretary putting on what she considers to be an excessive amount of makeup, and we get this sneakily hilarious pre-code exchange.
“Now, if you will answer my questions, you can go right back to your artwork.”
“Sure I remember the call, it was a man. He said Mrs. Parker was in trouble, so I put him right through.”
“Are you sure it was a man?”
“Well, it ain’t likely a woman would be calling me baby, is it?”
“No, not so far downtown as this. Now baby, I mean…”
Edna May Oliver was 49 when she made this movie, and the inspector, played by James Gleason, whom she calls “young man,” is 50. Age was a much different thing in the 1930s!
In looking it up, I see that there were six Miss Withers movies made in the 1930s, three with Edna May Oliver, (one of which is already on the DVR), one with Helen Broderick, and two with ZaSu Pitts. I think I know what I’m doing with my time in future, and it’s running down these movies if it kills me.